I’m now at the dreadful realization that I have squeezed in a little time and space to write and make art, but that I am willfully refusing to. I see clearly what is bubbling up to be expressed, and frankly I don’t want to do it. What wants to exist on page or on canvas touches upon things that I fear are too banal, vulnerable, unoriginal — the list could go on and on.
I could blame it on becoming a parent. I’m already a frighteningly sensitive person, and now my son blows open a new portal of acute feelings, including the most intense pangs of doubt, impatience, and heart-bursting ache for his welfare. I exist like an emotional puff pastry — flakes of feelings falling down onto my messy lap at the slightest jostle. Just a snippet of some violence done to a child on the fading ticker of the corner of the news channel I skipped over on my way to Downton Abbey… and I am on the verge of existential crisis.
And so it is this week, if the muse couldn’t corner me any more, I cross paths with the writings of psychotherapist and artist, Alice Miller.
Her premise is simple: Our culture is violent because we learn not to feel. It seems like old news now, but an insight that is all too ubiquitously relevant: Repressed feelings are a reaction to being hurt, often by parents, and that a child, completely dependent on those parents, must repress them or else be killed by the pain. A numb child can grow into an adult who lacks empathy for others, and in turn inflicts pain on their own children, as well as others.
Trust me I hear the groans from those who know me as overly sensitive and analytical. Obviously, this encompasses my own dealings with my childhood and shaping my son’s childhood, but more interestingly involves the resistance to writing this and avoiding the studio.
I’ve never met an artist who didn’t feel things deeply or who didn’t want to question things, even if it’s the story tickering off the corner of the news screen. And this requires an exploration of the “furthest countries of one’s secret soul,” because, as Rilke penned, the most profound and unique art is borne by those “who have faced the danger, gone to the very end of an experience, to the point beyond which no human being can go.” In my silly, little case, I just might have to face the danger of being too banal, vulnerable and unoriginal.
Turns out Alice Miller felt that creative work trumped all the years she practiced psychotherapy. That, as Gadamer agrees, in play, albeit serious play, can we visit places outside of where we were supposed to go, off the paths we were only allowed to go.
Alice Miller doesn’t go as far as I do here; that art opens up a beyond, past the prerequisite and unavoidable acknowledgment of what is true (and often painful) about ourselves and those around us. That if I recall the last time I was moved by music, writing, or art, I was taken to the edge of an experience where I could leap into a moment of not being anything at all. I could go with art into my very self-most straits, and set myself free.
(And only from that freedom — from my self, my needs, my projections, my ego — can I truly love someone else.)
Today’s Advice: “Only when we learn to transcend our death-bound selves in love, learn to take ourselves not too seriously, do we begin to truly live.” Karsten Harries
Wow – you nailed it.
I guess I understand ‘selfless’ love, but I don’t do that except in those existential moments. mostly love is doing…doing what needs to be done on a daily basis. the mundane acts of cooking, cleaning, caring for., listening, forgiving, letting go of the petty selfishness that is always present in me. thats why it’s work to maintain a relationship, to raise a child, to be a friend. I have to keep tabs on me. easy to be loving when no one is stepping on your toes.
For me, the doing-love is utterly self-less. I am giving a true gift, doing a loving deed, when I don’t expect anything in return, free from myself/ego/needs, so to speak, which is harder for me than it sounds. And I couldn’t agree more: The mundane self doesn’t disappear (except in rare moments), and can’t be avoided, which is why I have a hard time with New Age stuff. I think that’s why service to others is another art form….
Thanks always for your inspiring insight and food for thought!
XO
I always expect something in return. I have given up on that and trust myself most of the time to behave in a way that doesn’t make me ashamed of myself no matter what I expect. I love the idea that service is an art form. it makes it less mundane. wiping poopy bottoms doesn’t feel noble.
Never read such a concise totally on-target synopsis of Alice Miller. Her analysis of Hitler staggered me and made e gobble all her writings after that!
And funny, but maybe predictable, that she was detested for her insight. I thought of you and all those you stand up for, and somehow I think if the world felt a fraction of the pain they endure, injustices would be few and far between. Thank you always for your encouragement…. XO
Never read such a concise totally on-target synopsis of Alice Miller. Her analysis of Hitler staggered me and made e gobble all her writings after that! Yu do take her to an interesting place. Virginia Woolf wrote that a great novel allowed the reader tonwrite the chapter after the final one. You are doing that with Miller. Dare I suggest you swing a little longer on that artistic play swing?
Suggest away! Lest we are on the same page, I am currently needlepointing an image of a wartime massacre, my attempt to lovingly represent something horrific, so that others may share… anything that will urge them towards peace…. who knows. Cant’t wait to send you an image of it.
my daughter and I have been in a cautious dialogue about childhood lessons. She has more insight than I and has been gently leading me into the unknown. My unknown. It seems perhaps, that it is a possible journey, with a possible rich outcome. We both understand the nature of the adventure and how dangerous it is. so…we go slowly, feeling our way around the dark spots. Some places we probably won’t go, choosing to find some other understanding soul to explore with. But it has enriched our relationship, and my appreciation of her..and of me.